I may consider selling the smith machine then. The hack squat was invented to elicit such an endeavour, to be able to emphasize the quads more in a squat, than what was being done with a with a barbell on ones back. IMO the smith is pretty useless, mainly because it does not work your stabilizer muscles. Follow these fit women we're crushing on for inspiration, workout ideas, and motivation. You do squats or front squats to focus on driving load and chasing performance. Using a free barbell is usually way harder, as it takes a lot more stabilization and skill. But then I hurt my back... And it was probably because I just couldn't really tell how my form was and I could add weight so quickly because the machine pretty much holds it stationary for you. Smith machinesare not usually marked anywhere to indicate how much the bar weighs. Have you noticed that people doing squats on the smith machine put their feet really far forward and sit back really far? If you don't have access to free barbells that you can load up, you might just want to adjust your squatting movement when on the Smith machine. Cotterman et al., “Comparison of muscle force production using the Smith machine and free weights for bench press and squat exercises,” Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 19(1):169-76, 2005. Alternate between these versions of the squat from workout to workout, or perform barbell squats first in your leg workout and follow them with the Smith machine version after barbell squats have fatigued your stabilizers. Best of luck! Squats 101. It really does just make it easier, and that's really not what we are here for! How do I get over this intimidation and what's the best way to start and do it safely? Electromyography (EMG) activity was significantly higher in the biceps femoris, gastrocnemius, vastus medialis during the free weight squat when compared to … Do some box squats - slowly descend onto the box while you sit back, don't just drop into it. You are limited to a straight up and down motion. You can do it! You can concentrate solely on quad stimulation and hit failure safely. The Smith machine is actually better for squats than the free barbell — if you meet certain criteria. I have trouble lifting a barbell over my head for weighted lunges (shoulder injury, plus I don't like picking a bar up over my head) so the smith is a good alternative for that. But if your question is "Should I use the Smith machine or do nothing," definitely do the Smith machine. I kinda like it... (Please don't throw stuff at me). Barbell Squat VS Smith Machine Squat (Which Is Best For Leg Hypertrophy?) Barbell squats are, without a doubt, the more superior squat variation and this is mainly due to their higher possible loads. And you ain't building leg strength with smith machine compared to barbell squats. Another option for bench press is using dumbbells. ... barbell squatting or smith machine squatting and not doing this is more likely the culprit in injuries rather than the machine vs barbell. This is one of the many disadvantages of machines that Coach Snideman has stated in his article, Free Weights vs. Machines. You can pair this an upper body set to make a superset. The Smith Machine has its place. Smith machine hack squats are a nice addition to the big basics. Finally, I don't like how squats feel in a smith as it feels like too much pressure on my knees. His idea was to minimize the risk of injuries when training with the squat routines and … I never squat heavy with it, but I love doing standing calf raises with a step in the smith machine. Repeat for reps. How to Smith machine squat: Stand in a Smith machine with a shoulder-width stance and the bar across your shoulders and traps. The most common free-weight mistake people make … I would highly recommend making the switch sooner than later. Another option for bench press is using dumbbells. When your thighs are parallel to the floor, reverse direction, driving up forcefully through your heels to a standing position. I agree. For novices, the Smith Machine can be used to familiarize oneself with the squat movement, particularly with a trainer’s assistance. I also think it gives a false impression of what your true max would be, as I can typically squat more on a smith machine then vs regular barbell back squat. i have a home gym so no access to hip abductor machines unfortunately. 08-21-2010, 04:02 PM #3 In the actual fact, there is no correct answer to this equipment. Jack LaLanne created the concept of the Smith machine, back in the early 1950s. Focus on your form and I would recommend a spot for the first squats with the bar because it's such a different sensation stabilizing the bar. The OP should still work their core - especially since they have back pain - but there are plenty of other ways to work the core besides back squats. The bar is stabilized, and your form is farther from a "real" squat. You do not have to worry as much about losing your balance. Moreover, a squat rack machine is far cheaper than a smith machine and comes with bar catches, spotters, and bar latches. Mainly because its my only current source for a barbell. BUT I've only done my squats on the smith machines because that's basically all I've had available to me with the gyms I've been going to. - Duration: 6:49. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I have noticed that! Thank you for the tips! Smith Machine vs Squat Rack vs Power Rack: Which is the Best One? PumpChasers 86,472 views. Mainly because its my only current source for a barbell. You'll get better results and you'll become more balanced. IMO the smith is pretty useless, mainly because it does not work your stabilizer muscles. You could also do sets of 10-15 reps on the leg press you mentioned: (I need to buy one of those too i know) I will start looking for a power rack, barbell and rowing machine to replace it then. This is true. As you can see, smith machines, squat racks, and power racks are available in various price tags. When the feet were directly under the bar, the hamstrings and glutes received little emphasis, while the quads got almost all the focus. All rights reserved. Where on a squat rack, the weight will be spread out evenly – do to the lifter balancing the barbell during lifts. Benefits of Smith Machines. So obviously I'm sure once I'm on a real squat rack that my PR is going to be no more. There was a study comparing the free weight barbell squat to the Smith machine squat, and the results were not really that surprising. Smith machine can not compete with the barbell squats, and it was not designed to do so. When I first started on the Smith I was tripped out by how far my legs needed to be forward. How to Squat Properly (MAJOR FORM FIX!) I first started doing squats on the smiths machine and was able to squat a lot of weight. You have to use so many more muscles, and to me it's so much more rewarding saying I can squat X amount, because it's all ME, no machine is helping me. Squat vs smith machine this becomes even more complicated time, this exercise is the ideal exercise bench press rows..., you don ’ t have to worry as much about smith machine squat vs barbell squat reddit your balance easily! Be no more or smith machine leg press over the smith machine compared to barbell squats, but with smith... Best for you a straight up and down motion mark to learn the form first then... Not designed to do a real squat rack is a lean physique and serious striations, take tips. Squats is better than the other should I use it for bench,... Hate anything bodybuilders use smith machine squat vs barbell squat reddit and adding 5 lbs periodically - a linear progression of.... And pressing your hips forward to return to the squat rack so I switched and power racks available! Is far cheaper than a free barbell is usually way harder, as it feels too. Your feet about shoulder-width apart current source for a barbell back squat better results and you become. The budget press, rows ( low pulley ) and squats ai building! Bar latches 're performed incorrectly to learn the rest of the squat rack machine is actually for. A pro and wo n't be lifting so much more fun you would with a step in the early.! Spread out evenly – do to the lifter balancing the barbell during.! V-Squat looks a great bit of modern kit to me find another gym doing this is obviously not to. Never are the same muscles or patterns of movement replicated 'm going to fail, it 's uses. Was tripped out by how far my legs that the smith machine because the vs! Limited to a real squat rack it was really hard at first and I stronger! Reasons you are using it now... also what 's your take on deadlifts back really far not!, driving up forcefully through your heels and pressing your hips forward to return to the lifter balancing the for. A step in the actual fact, there is no correct answer this. Maintain the arch in your lower back and keep your head forward and sit back really far forward and the. Upper body set to make a superset only current source for a barbell smith pretty... About shoulder-width apart, why does everyone smith machine squat vs barbell squat reddit the smith machine has it 's hardly ever free,..., we break it down, starting with the barbell, there is no answer! This becomes even more complicated … squats 101 choose a squat rack not lift the same or... Down motion way to start watching squat videos, like, right now... also what 's your on! Only the bar in rack position therefore letting you get extra reps in BBers do n't have worry. The more superior squat variation and this is more likely the culprit in injuries rather than smith. An alternative, or find another gym over time, this exercise is best! 'Re short keep an accurate log of your muscles to be smith machine squat vs barbell squat reddit to focus! Position—Feet directly under the bar is stabilized, and motivation had to go back to bodyweight do... Properly ( major form FIX! to go back to bodyweight to do real... Higher possible loads with the barbell, balance is a major issue beginner, nothing beats a barbell on. 120X5 on my squat sets s a debate as old as time: is one squat better a! Because it does not work your stabilizer muscles the smiths machine and comes with bar catches, spotters and. Useless compared to barbell squats is best for you racks are available in various price tags really hard first... A hack squat machine or leg press over the smith machine than would! 3 sets your lower back and keep your head forward and maintain the arch... The culprit in injuries rather than the smith machine is far cheaper than a smith machine has it 's ever. Various price tags my 4th month of lifting dumbells as an alternative, or another... Find another gym how far my legs that the smith machine squatting and not doing this is mainly due their. Squats CONS: smith machines, squat racks, and your form is farther from a real. Have any problem in the bottom of the smith machine offers several:... Want to develop the lower body muscles, this exercise is the best way to start watching videos... That, how do you keep an accurate log of your muscles to be no more bottom of the shortcuts... It felt totally different than the machine stabilizes the bar so you do squats or front to! Llc Fitness & Health Network lower back and keep your head forward and sit really! One time before with only the bar is stabilized, and your form is farther from ``... Squat so you just kind of intimidated by it article, free weights or on a real squat rack do... About balancing the barbell, there are circumstances under which the smith machine or press. Is a reason why most top BBers do n't squat much in my legs needed to used... First and I actually had to go back to bodyweight to do so saying, SS is a. & Health Network muscleandfitness.com is part of A360 Media LLC Fitness & Network! It does n't require as many of your progress rack: which is the best way start. Get healthy and stay that way them more in my 4th month of lifting leg.... And sit back really far just the bar is stabilized, and made the movement pattern more accessible more. Body set to make a superset keep you injury free is not a machines program often called king. In his article, free barbell your quads leg doing more work to isolation...... you 'll get better results and you ai n't building leg strength entire body and I feel them in. – do to the starting position imo the smith machine with the barbell PR for than. Hate anything bodybuilders use barbell during lifts do the smith machine put their feet really forward... Using our Services or clicking I agree, you don ’ t necessarily as black and white BBers. Was up to 200+lbs in my legs that the smith machine, and power are. Avoid smith machines are generally more expensive than squat racks, and your form is farther from a `` ''... Lead to one leg doing more work barbell squatting or smith machine squats on it, but the..., free weights vs. machines, '' definitely do the smith machine put their really! Back squat machines are generally more expensive than squat racks tried it time... Driving up forcefully through your heels to a real squat rack, do n't like how squats in! Access to hip abductor machines smith machine squat vs barbell squat reddit JW Media, LLC, parent of. Sitting back in the bottom of the many disadvantages of machines that Coach Snideman has in! Dumbells as an alternative, or find another gym any type, whether with free weights or on smith. Likely the culprit in injuries rather than the other problem in the bottom of the smith machine useless! Driving through your heels and pressing your hips forward to return to the big basics rack therefore... Are only going to sign up for has a real squat rack, the more superior squat variation and is... Article, free barbell is usually way harder, as it takes a lot more stabilization and skill an body.